Monitoring and Evaluation
As MDG 3 Initiative Embarks on its Final Phase, Midterm Review Provides Guidance for the Road Ahead.
In an effort to track the progress and continuing obstacles to women's empowerment in its three-year MDG 3 Initiative, the Huairou Commission recently solicited the help of British review firm The IDL Group to write a midterm report with information provided by participating partners. Moving into the final phase of the initiative supported by the Dutch Foreign Ministry, the Huairou Commision is both inspired by the many successes of its member groups and dedicated to address the recommendations put forth in the review, the highlights of which are shared here.
According to the reviewers, "The MDG3AI should be highly praised for its dedicated contribution to supporting grassroots women's empowerment." The initiative has had "an impact on the partners beyond their individual projects, introducing them to new methodologies, as well as enhancing their organizational capacity and approaches." The IDL Group encourages the Huairou Cmmission to establish an overall monitoring and evaluation framework in consultation with its grassroots partners, in an effort to better measure the full impact on all indicators of empowerment.
The empowerment framework women leaders are applying through the MDG 3 Initiative deliberately expands the focus of progress beyond the official indicators set out by the Millennium Development agenda. The latter tracks the ratio of girls to boys in primary to tertiary education, the share of women in wage employment in the non-agricultural sector, and the proportions of seats held by women in the national parliament. More specifically, the MDG 3 Initiative aims to address the underlying prerequisites for women to assume leadership roles in their communities, including knowledge of policies, recognition of women's groups, and self-esteem. "Self-respect and self-esteem are often underrepresented in building women's strengths as role models, " says a leader of GROOTS Kenya in Gatundu in her evaluation. "A woman who is empowered has self-respect."
Mid-way results
Participants it the MDG 3 Initiative identified four areas for women's empowerment: governance and leadership, accountability, organizing and grassroots investment, and resource sovereignty. Progress was booked in all areas, as women gained access to land titles and credit, increased the responsiveness of local government to community concerns, and increased their advocacy base through peer exchanges across groups and regions.
Examples of change
In Ghana, where the custom is for men to inherit family land and where unequal land distribution continues to be an underlying cause of poverty, women from the Grassroots Sisterhood Foundation (GSF) successfully lobbied the heads of the Customary Land Secretariat (CLS) in Tamale to include three women in each of the three Chief Courts for decisions on land. They also supported the creation of a gender desk to cater to women's concerns and participation in the CLS. Seven leaders from CLS partner Grassroots Rural Women have accessed lands totaling 120 acres through engaging their traditional leaders for the allocation of land for farming and are leading in advocacy for security of tenure. There is an expectation that more groups will be allocated land in the coming year.
In India, Swayam Shikshan Prayog (SSP), has increased the quality and access to services in their communities, most notably healthcare and banking. By training women to become health promoters and by forming health governance groups, SSP's women hold health providers accountable for delivering high-quality health services to traditionally underserved constituencies. In addition, the SSP federation has worked along with local banks in an effort to extend banking services to poor communities. In the course of this campaign, 80 women leaders reached out to a total of 36 commercial banks to help locals set up bank accounts at zero balance.
Uganda's Community-Based Organization for Child Welfare (UCOBAC) trained 20 grassroots women to approach 180 elected officials to discuss women's participation in decision-making processes. In 2009-2010, the organization mobilized grassroots women to survey and map women`s political and decision making participation, resulting in an evidence-based advocacy document to support participation and engagement in decision-making bytwo groups of women: elected or appointed and grassroots women.
These examples speak to changes in attitude and increases in responsiveness of government toward women, most notably government recognizing and actively seeking women's expertise. All of these are indicators of progress, as defined by women in the Initiative.
Out of the four main areas of empowerment, the review found that participants placed more emphasis on governance and leadership than on the other three areas for empowerment. This suggests that grassroots women consider real empowerment to come from changes in the space of engagement.
Challenges
While these successes are invigorating and worth celebrating, many challenges remain for women in the process of establishing personal autonomy and becoming change agents in their families and communities.
One such challenge is the culturally embedded stigmatization of women leaders. Negative characterizations of women in leadership as prostitutes and bad mothers continue to keep women from assuming prominent roles in their communities, regardless of progress booked by many participants in the MDG 3 Initiative.
Another often-overlooked obstacle is a lack of connection between women from different strata of political engagement. Women in elected leadership positions from more privileged backgrounds don't necessarily relate to the struggles of grassroots women activists, which stands in the way of the former becoming mentors and role models to women at the grassroots.
A lack of responsiveness of government officials to women wanting to hold government accountable continues to be a major challenge, regardless of successes by many of the groups participating in the initiative.
Progress
The midterm review recognizes the undeniable progress made by grassroots women through the MDG 3 Initiative in taking on the above challenges, but also reminds all participants and Huairou that continued programming and funding for women's initiatives will be essential to overcoming systemic obstacles to women's participation and empowerment.
Recommendations and responses
To further enhance the quality and delivery of the MDG 3 Initiative, the IDL group made a number of recommendations, including
- the creation of an overarching organizational measurement and evaluation framework
- the creation of thematiclearning pieces
- creative thinking on how to best provide learning opportunitiesaround governance and accountability
The Huairou Commission is responding to these recommendations by expanding its current monitoring framework to include an organization-wide set of measurements for progress, while continuing to value and highlight less-quantifiable aspect of empowerment, like self-esteem. The coordinators of the MDG 3 Initiative, in addition, are working on creating thematic material that can be used as learning pieces by participating groups who currently fully rely on assembling their own materials. These pieces will serve to enhance Huairou's signature focus on learning by doing, which the IDL Group identified as one of the organization's strong points. In addition, video profiles of partners' work in the field as well as articles in the MDG 3 "Women's Empowerment Series" allow network members to learn from each other's many achievements, and to duplicate strategies.
In an effort to provide engaging learning opportunities around governance and accountability, Huairou is happy to announce the Global Summit on Grassroots Women's Leadership and Governance to be held in the beginning of March 3-8 2011. The summit will bring together grassroots women from Africa, Asia and Latin America, to expand women's knowledge of political processes and capacity to engage with authority figures, and to help them find collective solutions to common struggles.
Representatives of local governments, academics and multi-national organizations will join grassroots leaders in this global exchange.
In line with IDL's recommendations, the Huairou Commission will perform a final review of the MDG 3 Initiative at the end of the three-year project in 2011 and is looking forward to seeing the progress that these and other improvements to the Initiative will bring about.
In moving forward, Huairou is welcoming further input from its network members, while continuing to highlight the exciting successes of participants in the MDG 3 Initiative in its publications.